Magistrate Tonjeni exits bench after controversial Sibanyoni ruling

The retirement of Chief Magistrate Tuletu Tonjeni has effectively brought an end to any potential disciplinary action against her following the controversial handling of the Joe “Ferrari” Sibanyoni matter.

Tonjeni officially retired on 29 May 2026, just days after a complaint was lodged over her decision to remove the high-profile extortion and money laundering case from the court roll. Legal sources indicate that the Magistrates Commission no longer has jurisdiction to pursue disciplinary proceedings against retired magistrates.

The controversy stems from proceedings in the Kwaggafontein Magistrate’s Court on 15 and 18 May, where Tonjeni struck the case off the roll after prosecutor Mkhuseli Ntaba failed to appear in court. The ruling resulted in the immediate release of Sibanyoni and his co-accused.

The decision sparked criticism and prompted a formal complaint to the Magistrates Commission, with concerns raised about the handling of a case involving serious allegations against the prominent taxi boss.

Despite the setback, the National Prosecuting Authority (NPA) moved swiftly to revive the matter. The case was subsequently re-enrolled in Delmas, leading to the re-arrest of Sibanyoni and three co-accused. The four were later granted bail of R70,000 each.

The case is scheduled to return to court on 1 September as prosecutors continue with the matter. However, Tonjeni’s retirement means questions surrounding her decision are unlikely to be tested through a disciplinary process.