ActionSA objects to Andrea Johnson for NPA head

ActionSA has raised objections to the shortlisting of Advocate Andrea Johnson for the position of National Director of Public Prosecutions (NDPP), citing concerns over her suitability for the role. The party said Johnson’s performance during her interview with the Ad-hoc Committee and statements made in prior meetings cast doubt on her ability to restore public confidence in South Africa’s prosecuting authority.

In a statement released on Thursday, ActionSA said Johnson’s comments advising prosecutors to “fake it until you make it” when handling serious cases raised serious questions about her judgment and professionalism. “The role of the NDPP has never been more critical, and no candidate facing serious questions over their integrity can be considered fit for the position when what is required is someone beyond reproach,” the party said.

ActionSA highlighted that Johnson recently appeared before the Ad-hoc Committee, where her interview performance failed to inspire confidence that she could meet the demands of leading the NPA. The party said growing concerns about her capability and integrity were mirrored in public commentary submitted during the shortlisting process, demonstrating a lack of widespread confidence in her candidacy.

The party also referenced Johnson’s criticism of KwaZulu-Natal Police Commissioner Lt General Nhlanhla Mkhwanazi, who has been at the forefront of exposing corruption within the South African Police Service, the judiciary, and criminal syndicates. ActionSA suggested that her stance in these matters raises further doubts about her alignment with the reforms needed to restore the NPA’s credibility.

Advocate Shamila Batohi, the current NDPP, is set to retire in January 2026. Interviews for her successor are currently underway at Lynnwood Manor, Pretoria. The six shortlisted candidates include Advocates Nicolette Astraid Bell, Hermione Cronje, Andrea Johnson, Xolisile Khanyile, Adrian Mopp, and Menzi Simelane.

ActionSA reiterated that the NPA requires an unimpeachable leader to reverse the decline of the institution and rebuild public trust. “Advocate Johnson’s interview performance and public statements provide no confidence that she is fit for the job. Her candidacy does not meet the standards needed to restore the integrity of the National Prosecuting Authority,” the party said.

The organisation’s statement follows earlier objections to the shortlisting of Advocate Menzi Simelane. ActionSA emphasised that the next NDPP must be someone whose integrity is unquestionable and who can lead the prosecuting authority effectively in a context of heightened scrutiny and ongoing investigations into corruption and criminality within the justice system.

The selection process for the new NDPP is a critical moment for South Africa’s justice system, as public confidence in prosecutorial institutions remains fragile. The interviews this week are expected to conclude before the end of the year, paving the way for the appointment of a new head in January 2026 when Batohi steps down.